Case Studies

Accessible Nonprofit Websites: Compliance, Best Practices, and Legal Landscape

By EZUD Published · Updated

Accessible Nonprofit Websites: Compliance, Best Practices, and Legal Landscape

Nonprofits exist to serve communities, and inaccessible websites directly contradict that mission. When a person with a disability cannot donate, volunteer, access services, or find information on a nonprofit’s website, the organization fails in its core purpose. Despite this, nonprofit website accessibility often receives less attention than corporate or government accessibility. This article examines the legal requirements, current state, and practical steps for nonprofit digital accessibility.

The legal requirements for nonprofit website accessibility are less clear-cut than for government agencies or public accommodations, but the trend is toward enforcement:

ADA Title III. Nonprofits that operate as places of public accommodation (which includes most organizations that serve the public) may be subject to Title III requirements. In February 2025, a Minnesota federal judge ruled that websites qualify as places of public accommodation under Title III, potentially expanding the scope of ADA web accessibility requirements for private organizations including nonprofits.

ADA Title II. Nonprofits that receive state or local government funding or operate government programs may be subject to Title II requirements, including the 2024 rule mandating WCAG 2.1 Level AA compliance.

Section 504. Nonprofits receiving federal financial assistance are subject to Section 504 nondiscrimination requirements, which courts have increasingly interpreted to include digital accessibility.

While no federal law explicitly mandates WCAG compliance for all private nonprofits, the legal trajectory is clear. Courts are expanding the definition of public accommodation to include websites, and any nonprofit that receives government funding faces direct compliance obligations.

Current State of Nonprofit Accessibility

The picture is not encouraging. The WebAIM Million study found that 95.9% of home pages across the web have accessibility errors, and nonprofits are not exceptions. Common issues include:

  • Donation forms. The most critical page on many nonprofit websites is often one of the least accessible. Form fields without labels, unclear error messages, and CAPTCHA challenges block screen reader and keyboard users from completing donations.
  • Event registration. Registration pages with date pickers, session selectors, and payment forms frequently lack keyboard accessibility.
  • Document downloads. Annual reports, tax filings, and program information published as flat PDFs without tags.
  • Image-heavy design. Nonprofits often rely on emotional imagery to convey their mission, but these images frequently lack alt text.
  • Low contrast. Many nonprofit websites use branded color schemes that prioritize aesthetics over readability, resulting in low-contrast text.

Why Accessibility Matters for Nonprofits Beyond Compliance

Donor reach. People with disabilities and their families control significant spending power. An inaccessible donation page means lost revenue.

Service delivery. If a nonprofit serves people with disabilities (even partially), an inaccessible website prevents the people who most need services from accessing them.

Grant requirements. An increasing number of government and foundation grants include accessibility requirements. Nonprofits with inaccessible websites may lose funding eligibility.

Mission alignment. For organizations that advocate for equity, inclusion, or human rights, an inaccessible website creates a credibility problem.

Practical Steps

Nonprofits typically operate with limited budgets, making a prioritized approach essential:

  1. Fix the donation page first. Ensure all form fields have labels, error messages are clear, and the entire flow works with keyboard and screen reader.
  2. Add alt text to key images. Focus on mission-critical images: program photos, event images, and infographics.
  3. Use accessible templates. WordPress, Squarespace, and other CMS platforms offer accessibility-checked themes. Starting with an accessible base reduces remediation work.
  4. Caption all video. Free and low-cost captioning tools (YouTube auto-captions, Otter.ai) make this achievable on a nonprofit budget.
  5. Test with free tools. WAVE, axe DevTools, and Lighthouse are free accessibility checking tools that identify the most common issues.

For related content, see accessible news media websites and worst accessibility fails and lessons learned. For the full collection, visit the universal design case studies guide.

Key Takeaways

  • Nonprofits face growing legal risk as courts expand ADA public accommodation definitions to include websites, and organizations receiving government funds face direct compliance obligations.
  • Donation forms, event registration, and image-heavy designs are the most common accessibility failures on nonprofit websites.
  • Accessibility directly affects donor reach, service delivery, grant eligibility, and mission credibility.
  • Budget-constrained nonprofits should prioritize donation pages, alt text, accessible CMS templates, video captioning, and free testing tools.

Sources

More in Case Studies

Universal Design Case Studies Guide: How Leading Organizations Build Accessibility Guide Worst Accessibility Fails and Lessons Learned Accessible Startup Design From Day One: Building Inclusion Into Your Product University Website Accessibility Compliance: Legal Requirements and Implementation

View all Case Studies articles →